{
  "judgeId": "ai:worthbuilding:editorial-judge-v1",
  "judge": "Codex AI assistant",
  "evaluatedAt": "2026-09-29",
  "rubricVersion": 2,
  "criteria": [
    "usefulness",
    "originality",
    "feasibility",
    "clarity"
  ],
  "scale": "1 (weak) to 5 (strong)",
  "rule": "One AI judge awards max(0, 2 \u00d7 (total score \u2212 13)) weighted upvote points per idea. Points represent the strength of this single AI evaluation, not separate voters. No human demand or purchase claims.",
  "evaluations": [
    {
      "slug": "one-place-to-run-a-small-saas",
      "title": "One place to run a small SaaS",
      "contentHash": "d0d495a32e6a380e7707d0ffab18e95a63f4b2c371468e267734f40086d0c028",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Useful daily founder workflow; broad integration scope makes the first release harder.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "voice-notes-worth-coming-back-to",
      "title": "My best ideas are in voice notes I never listen to again",
      "contentHash": "b641f4e389b74acc56e709d3769380c7a0f0581cb567bdad8ff6b80bf8c2c610",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Clear retrieval problem and feasible transcription workflow; many existing alternatives.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "consistent-product-photos-from-ordinary-shots",
      "title": "My product photos look like five different brands",
      "contentHash": "51f78806b75a09374e52de38ac99ac854e605e4eb34aa89f00c8a3899df1e93f",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Consistent catalogs have practical value; preserving product details needs careful review.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "turn-study-notes-into-practice-games",
      "title": "My notes need to become practice, not another summary",
      "contentHash": "11b41f5e8c512dcdd01a9c77476ac0a05ec9dd3220d5bbc8fa08e5ff512228a0",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Source-linked practice is useful and approachable; differentiation is limited.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "a-searchable-memory-for-dnd-campaigns",
      "title": "Our D&D campaign has years of history and nobody remembers it",
      "contentHash": "7ab09945c0eb51e73f11b9d5656f24c29cfbec9a17e698220a89e040b7f86c5d",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 4,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Specific recurring campaign-memory problem with a manageable notes-first scope.",
      "votePoints": 8
    },
    {
      "slug": "reproduce-bugs-from-customer-videos",
      "title": "A customer sent a bug video. Reproducing it took the entire afternoon.",
      "contentHash": "28f1e19216f42ba7ec72f2a76bf9310cc9042c2580d4fd927c63f77b35c983b6",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 4,
        "feasibility": 2,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Strong developer benefit; inferring reproducible state from video remains difficult.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "keep-help-videos-current",
      "title": "Our help videos are outdated every time we ship",
      "contentHash": "a502fb745054d1b8bda134ec1e7cdc93fedca67f5904446cd77626c07fb23653",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 4,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Release-aware tutorial maintenance is distinctive; screen dependency tracking is challenging.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "try-software-before-signup",
      "title": "People should be able to try the product before creating an account",
      "contentHash": "e837e45eea68d57a03ebce51b9f73d40d973c8a24f9ab3d1bfadba73421695fd",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Reduces evaluation friction with an achievable narrow sandbox; established competition.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "realistic-data-for-testing-apps",
      "title": "My app looks great with five users. I have no idea what happens with 50,000.",
      "contentHash": "91dfe4410daafd73dc86c74804eab10fa907b4ef1b1eb415c567e65a48dd5ee0",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Connected repeatable test scenarios solve a concrete builder problem.",
      "votePoints": 8
    },
    {
      "slug": "turn-business-spreadsheets-into-apps",
      "title": "This spreadsheet is running our business, and everyone is afraid to touch it",
      "contentHash": "3b7f282eed77df00408b474ca1c1356245a1d0ffe349b39b6ebdf75f6a5ee3a1",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 2,
        "clarity": 4
      },
      "total": 13,
      "reason": "Useful but importing arbitrary workbook logic and permissions is a large undertaking.",
      "votePoints": 0
    },
    {
      "slug": "quotes-from-site-visit-notes",
      "title": "Writing the quote takes longer than inspecting the job",
      "contentHash": "9befbf72d548c2bcc77f4be49e4a64d377a91456f38fde49949299d321a76fb1",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Trade-specific draft quotes have a clear workflow and realistic human review.",
      "votePoints": 8
    },
    {
      "slug": "client-portals-from-project-templates",
      "title": "Every new client means rebuilding the same portal",
      "contentHash": "dedad4c11ddc5e3d00003b2e6fae97bfc20456e4b8832f34886230a6a54baef2",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 5,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Straightforward reusable project setup; requires differentiation from existing portals.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "a-launch-kit-from-product-assets",
      "title": "One product launch turns into a week of making content",
      "contentHash": "ed9ef86128caf4e1f09e0261f5a29f80597bd6116dfb8f4c8c268d7807621216",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Practical launch assistance with an achievable three-format starting point.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "search-a-store-by-what-you-need",
      "title": "Our store search only works if customers know the exact product name",
      "contentHash": "d21d337087da2d80e6ec37f42e928ce946c951f5ee69322af1e63535a76acb40",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Attribute-grounded search is useful; catalog quality constrains reliable matching.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "track-how-ai-describes-a-business",
      "title": "AI recommends our competitors. What is it saying about us?",
      "contentHash": "1a6a54974bf31a5ed76ba239718d323acd44258fa750db11e5262153c34a156e",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 3,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 14,
      "reason": "Inspectable answer monitoring is feasible; business impact and repeatability are uncertain.",
      "votePoints": 2
    },
    {
      "slug": "competitor-changes-with-visual-context",
      "title": "I don\u2019t want competitor alerts. I want to know what actually changed.",
      "contentHash": "19aebd1ddc249ded9d83fb8c1625d95fe251a9299a3d8aaffc4bb93c6055b000",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Evidence-based visual changes improve noisy monitoring with a focused scope.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "catch-broken-translated-interfaces",
      "title": "The translation is correct, but the interface is broken",
      "contentHash": "a32613e59127e5d2847aa6db84deb15b8ae02829dc6653f69d50c125867a19da",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 4,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 18,
      "reason": "Concrete localization checks offer actionable developer value and a bounded MVP.",
      "votePoints": 10
    },
    {
      "slug": "compare-ai-models-on-real-workflows",
      "title": "A cheaper AI model might work. I\u2019m scared to switch.",
      "contentHash": "b894c8e3cb51b7817382a4844e480656a901759ffd1e62e6d13cafda3b185f07",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Workflow-specific evaluation solves a practical model selection problem.",
      "votePoints": 8
    },
    {
      "slug": "feature-requests-with-customer-evidence",
      "title": "We keep building the loudest feature request",
      "contentHash": "eea357e2e3df1d74a09e45053d2b7e64023aefea5c93487f69cc1e4422bc6f36",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Evidence aggregation improves planning; the category already has strong alternatives.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "interview-practice-for-a-specific-job",
      "title": "I need interview practice for this job, not random questions",
      "contentHash": "47033f3ace824b21d04fd07cae2c006063f39217e4715ef2b2d4636fa946d9b3",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Tailored rehearsal is useful but crowded and hard to distinguish.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "practice-skills-between-course-lessons",
      "title": "I saved the course, but I need to practice the skill",
      "contentHash": "d42e10cf5061ba415abd6ade53c553063dc583b9d63f3c6897d7efbfcc011c38",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Task-based learning with explicit checks has a concrete achievable benefit.",
      "votePoints": 8
    },
    {
      "slug": "room-layouts-that-respect-dimensions",
      "title": "The room makeover looks amazing\u2014until the furniture doesn\u2019t fit",
      "contentHash": "33b4d064fbd20e2daad2f9d1acb9f5575c768593c534b79ccc4cdb4aa5d5e596",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Measured fit addresses a real purchase concern; accurate room entry adds friction.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "track-shared-equipment-with-qr-codes",
      "title": "We own the equipment. Nobody knows where it is.",
      "contentHash": "36a5c16a54c3cfb9c3967e0914a4a90e1b7cd5f16e1e8a062ab6e705267ec036",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 5,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Simple checkout records solve an operational problem with modest technical scope.",
      "votePoints": 8
    },
    {
      "slug": "a-video-feedback-workspace-for-coaches",
      "title": "My clients send workout videos, and reviewing them eats my evening",
      "contentHash": "4b9e87831c692de11bb8f9d27a70c8d41d0685fc9dfb344c8d74a41155229073",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Timestamped coach review improves a repeated workflow without relying on automated diagnosis.",
      "votePoints": 8
    },
    {
      "slug": "turn-articles-into-editable-infographics",
      "title": "I want to turn this article into a visual people actually save",
      "contentHash": "384423cd11584f7dd9ec0c87b9328f2918f69be815a7f8512db4b6a702caeeaa",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 14,
      "reason": "Editable sourced graphics are useful; reliable extraction and layout still require review.",
      "votePoints": 2
    },
    {
      "slug": "a-sales-board-for-customer-dms",
      "title": "Customers ask about buying in DMs, then disappear in my inbox",
      "contentHash": "5139ad8576f8d36cc8d7c93f0969ccb8ae9415a0ed61ad58aefbad43b76da8f4",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 2,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Strong sales workflow; messaging platform permissions can block reliable integration.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "a-receptionist-for-busy-local-businesses",
      "title": "I miss customer calls whenever I\u2019m doing the actual work",
      "contentHash": "80077da9380ca29f3327bc3d9c4bb733dab28b17da0cf540f69a9cc004fc1fe0",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 2,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 14,
      "reason": "Clear business pain; voice reliability and booking escalation complicate delivery.",
      "votePoints": 2
    },
    {
      "slug": "turn-raw-footage-into-reviewable-clips",
      "title": "I have hours of footage and nothing ready to post",
      "contentHash": "9961715fda426706b04dd913729c5269b34e330241c976de5da4971c1e60c43f",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 14,
      "reason": "Helpful editing workflow in a crowded category with significant media processing.",
      "votePoints": 2
    },
    {
      "slug": "recreate-outfits-with-your-own-wardrobe",
      "title": "I like the outfit in this photo. Can I make it with clothes I own?",
      "contentHash": "3de20475527ecd2846209bd5d69a63add8907bf78e7cd61a364252fa41b24e9d",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 3,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 14,
      "reason": "Interesting reuse of owned clothes; wardrobe capture and matching create adoption friction.",
      "votePoints": 2
    },
    {
      "slug": "explore-room-styles-before-shopping",
      "title": "I want to see the room makeover before buying anything",
      "contentHash": "c8a3b09245858f32f96c7c9944d28957eb66c0b242571be64ba95f89c9c072a4",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 3,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 13,
      "reason": "Useful inspiration, but crowded and less grounded than measured planning.",
      "votePoints": 0
    },
    {
      "slug": "learning-paths-through-youtube-tutorials",
      "title": "I watched ten tutorials and still don\u2019t know what to learn next",
      "contentHash": "9eb0cfe79dd922f042e35ae7c0a7cbd4d0062f6e8fea5aadf616b36c49055a91",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Reviewed pathways plus projects offer a sensible curated learning MVP.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "rehearse-difficult-conversations-by-voice",
      "title": "I need to rehearse the conversation before having it",
      "contentHash": "9917ea6e826807afa6485ed704b92a52a988742b32663bf333bae8fa6096dac1",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Specific role-play scenarios are useful; actionable voice feedback needs care.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "practice-language-for-real-travel-scenarios",
      "title": "Teach me the language I\u2019ll actually use on this trip",
      "contentHash": "92c8f577e7650ae98f3929449ccc4e48c659611fc42db05988ccdeb49da215af",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Narrow travel practice is approachable; differentiation from language apps is modest.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "find-saved-links-by-what-you-remember",
      "title": "My bookmarks are a graveyard of things I meant to use",
      "contentHash": "19472873fa984c45104397e5d07357724fcc350221b6aeccbf6098c09fb92b4b",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Meaning-based retrieval helps scattered collections but faces established alternatives.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "help-articles-from-resolved-support-questions",
      "title": "Our support inbox already contains the answers our help center is missing",
      "contentHash": "cd6e9b59577027f52fdb6669b91f4efd8be96358e7350cc9228b9c0d3b6f0bb2",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Reviewed drafts reuse existing support knowledge with clear source evidence.",
      "votePoints": 8
    },
    {
      "slug": "polished-product-videos-from-screen-recordings",
      "title": "I want to explain my app without spending a day making a video",
      "contentHash": "7fba56a6c7149c83f37c733b3b367854f69912f06d01aded2230baa7ffded5e7",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Short browser demo polishing is practical and scoped, though crowded.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "test-thumbnail-ideas-with-real-feedback",
      "title": "Which thumbnail would people actually click?",
      "contentHash": "969ee4189c167a514b69d1c15b82e9af9955c2ad30d1336d89827c7110da4619",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Honest preference testing is feasible; recruiting a relevant audience is the main hurdle.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "content-ideas-from-your-video-comments",
      "title": "There are thousands of comments under my videos. What should I make next?",
      "contentHash": "41b2d6fee38d25e81cad407dc9eeb045f67d157ee5c15a08526b96d437b09570",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 4,
        "originality": 3,
        "feasibility": 4,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 16,
      "reason": "Evidence-linked themes provide useful creator research and a clear first version.",
      "votePoints": 6
    },
    {
      "slug": "find-unused-software-seats-and-subscriptions",
      "title": "We\u2019re paying for tools and seats nobody uses",
      "contentHash": "f4be2d0a41adcb8a58c44414f8df41835e7e05886f6bd3fbb486ff2477d0c5a0",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 3,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 15,
      "reason": "Clear cost-review benefit; provider usage access limits automation.",
      "votePoints": 4
    },
    {
      "slug": "simple-bookings-for-chat-based-businesses",
      "title": "Getting bookings through WhatsApp shouldn\u2019t require twenty messages",
      "contentHash": "19c568f9b7beeeb235a895a70b6935683df8cb16c43cbd6fe8cdb4149f00be21",
      "scores": {
        "usefulness": 5,
        "originality": 2,
        "feasibility": 5,
        "clarity": 5
      },
      "total": 17,
      "reason": "Concrete scheduling friction and simple scope; many substitutes already exist.",
      "votePoints": 8
    }
  ],
  "storage": "Each point has a reserved ai:worthbuilding:editorial-judge-v1:point:N identifier. These identifiers represent vote units, not accounts or independent judges. The previous single-vote allocation is replaced."
}
